Yesterday I blogged about Marvel and DC telling the torrent site Z-Cult FM to take down their material, as well as a message allegedly from SLG Publishing, giving Z-Cult permission to list SLG’s material on the site. It was that second item that really snowballed over the weekend.
Johanna Draper Carlson of Comics Worth Reading contacted SLG Publishing Dan Vado, and he said nobody at SLG wrote the letter. He also left a comment about it on the Z-Cult site.
Z-Cult pulled the thread down and contacted Dan. Someone from Z-Cult then posted a comment here on Blog@ saying they had heard from Dan; it turns out the person who sent the message to Z-Cult was a freelancer who has worked for SLG and had been in contact with Z-Cult before on SLG’s behalf.
That brings us to an email Dan sent me, after I forwarded Z-Cult’s comment to him to verify it was accurate. As it turns out, Dan did give the freelancer permission to contact the site on his behalf some time back to arrange a banner ad exchange:
Looks like I owe a couple of people some apologies on this. Let me break this down for everyone.
1) In regards to the statement on Zcult attributed to SLG. I did not write it. However…
2) Someone whom I have done a lot of business with over the years DID write it. This person had asked me some time back if I would be willing to allow some torrenting of our material in exchange for ad banners on those same sites. This was a few months back and something I thought had already been done. In my mind this was supposed to be a low key promotional opportunity to see if people using those torrent sites could be persuaded to buy legal downloads and not a grand statement on the overall rightness or wrongness of torrent sites.
3) The fact that this took a long time to get done wound up being bad timing as I was now being painted as being pro-torrent, anti DC and Marvel. Those companies have the right to do whatever they like with their property, including threatening legal action. That I might find some promotional use for these download sites doesn’t change that. The timing of the statement was very poor and caught me off guard while I was on vacation and made it look like our decision was a reaction to the Marvel/DC thing and not an initiative we took on our own.
4) I made some pretty harsh comments about the quality of comics journalism. While nobody covering comics is ever going to win a pulitzer, in this case I have to take responsibility for being out of line.
So, with a load of egg on my face I would like to sincerely apologize to Serj at Zcult, to Landry Walker who has been nothing but a tireless and hard-working friend and colleague, and to everyone whom I may have offended in general.