Blackest Night: Black Lantern Corp v.1 & 2
Written by Peter J. Tomasi, James Robinson, J.T. Krul, Geoff Johns, Tony Bedard & Greg Rucka
Penciled by Ardian Syaf, Eddy Barrows, Allan Goldman, Ed Benes, Scott Kolins, Marcos Marz, Eduardo Pansica & Nicola Scott
Inked by Vicente Cifuentes, John Dell, Ruy José, Julio Ferreira, Eber Ferreira, Rob Hunter, Jon Sibal, JP Mayer, Scott Williams, Ed Benes, Kolins, Luciana Del Negro, Barrows, Wayne Faucher, Sandro Ribeiro, Prentis Rollins, Jonathan Glapion, Walden Wong & Drew Geraci
Colored by Nei Ruffino, Rod Reis, Hi-Fi Design & Mike Atiyeh
Lettered by John J. Hill, Steve Wands, Rob Clark, Jr., Travis Lanham & Rob Leigh
Published by DC Comics
Okay, yes, the art is choppy. Those credits include a metric ton of pencilers and even more inkers. Most of the art is credible, but the sheer number of artistic voices does add a sense of inconsistency within each series. One penciler handles most of each miniseries, so it’s not completely jarring, but you’ll notice some art discrepancies.
Black Lantern Corps v. 1 and 2 compile six different three-issue miniseries that tie into the Blackest Night miniseries. Vol. 1 collects Batman, Superman and Titans, while v.2 brings together Flash, Justice Society of America and Wonder Woman. The overall effect of reading all six series is an impression that the heroes’ victory over Blackest Night is largely pyrrhic. The sheer number of people killed in these two books makes a reader wonder if the heroes really are accomplishing anything. Tomasi has Batman and Red Robin repeatedly state that their primary objective is to protect the innocent, yet dozens of Gotham police officers are killed on their watch.
Which isn’t to say that, taken on its own, any individual series isn’t without its redeeming points. Superman, in particular, manages high octane action, a fair amount of creepy terror, and the most effective use of the over-used emotional spectrum view of the characters. Wonder Woman, by comparison, feels jumpy and uneven, despite a strong opening narration wherein Greg Rucka examines Wonder Woman’s character quite nicely.
In the big picture, some entertainment lurks between these pages, but reading three straight Black Lantern Corps series (one volume), or all six (both volumes), probably isn’t necessary. The repetition of themes (heroes’ regret over losses, rage over desecration of loved ones) and humorless struggles against zombie heroes add up to less than the sum of each individual serial. Once you’ve read one of these Blackest Night tie-ins, you’ve read them all. Stick to your favorite hero and enjoy one ride; six won’t add much to the experience.