Chad Nevett considers the end of Avengers Vs. X-Men, and how it ties into All-New X-Men and the all-new X-Men status quo in general:
The goal is the event was to get here. Sorry, a goal of the event was to get here. The story told in the event was a goal as well. But, ever since Bendis took over the Avengers titles, one of the major patterns in the Marvel Universe was that each event or new status quo seemed to exist to lead to the next, usually in an alternating pattern. Event A led to New Status Quo A, which led to Event B, which led to New Status Quo B, which led to Event C, which led to New Status Quo C, etc. There were stories in there and I enjoyed quite a few of them. But, there was also a general feeling of the events and new status quos not delivering all that they could, because part of their function was to produce what came next. That was something that I felt really hindered Avengers vs. X-Men where there was such a focus on hitting All-New X-Men #1 that the story being told didn’t match the story they were trying to tell. Cyclops needed to be in this role, so everyone ignores that he was right and they never gave him any credit, nor recognised their roles in driving him to extreme measures by the end. There was a sense that they failed to see that, by the end of Avengers vs. X-Men, Cyclops was the hero and Captain America was the villain who just happened to win…
That last line put me in mind, more than anything else, of Civil War back in 2006/2007; it felt, at the time, that Iron Man was definitely the “villain” of that event who again “just happened to win,” and that throughline was somewhat followed through and somewhat ignored in the many comics that followed (Certainly, Cap-as-martyr was a big thing afterwards, underscoring his role as hero-who-fell, and Iron Man seemed to be played up as undeserving ruler somewhat, at least through World War Hulk). It makes me wonder if, as Marvel continues to set characters against each other for these types of storylines, the way that “everyone” can win is that the loser is given the moral upper hand in some way…









