I can only speak for myself here, but since hearing about the news that Zack Snyder has been named director of the next Superman film, “The Man of Steel”, I’ve come to some pretty definite conclusions about what I would and would not like to see. While I’m sure debate will continue about the choice of Snyder (my own pick would have been Brad Bird, currently locked up with “Mission: Impossible IV”), I think that he might be capable of making a fast-moving, visceral Superman film that we haven’t seen before. As for the rest of it . . .
1) Enough of the Origin: I said this elsewhere, but it bears repeating: “We all know the origin. Superman’s origin is so well-known that my mother, my grandparents, and my cats could all recount it (I shouldn’t really need to specify that my dad, my wife, and my kids know it). Confine it to the opening credits if you must show it at all.”
2) F@#$ Subtle: I like character. I like nuance. I like the underpinnings of human behavior. This is SUPERMAN. And we haven’t seen Superman really, truly unload on screen. Even in “Superman Returns”, with its great plane crash sequence, most of the rest of his action involved the lifting of heavy objects. And that was about it. Even if we have two hours of the most beautifully crafted acting and humanely rendered interpersonal communication, give us a good half-hour of him beating the unholy crap out of Bizarro or something. He’s the MAN OF STEEL. Show it.
3) A Different Villain/A Different Montage: I understand that Zod will be the villain again. I suppose it’s too late to change that, but I’m fairly tired of the fact that Luthor or Zod must always be the villain. Out of five “Superman” movies, Luthor figured in four of them; Zod and gang were in “II” and Zod was in a lot of “Smallville” lately. Apart from beating the crap out of himself in “Superman III”, Superman on the big-screen has only fought a computer-possessed businessman’s sister (III) and the manicure-challenged Nuclear Man (IV) outside of Luthor and Zod’s gang.
Compare that to Batman, who has gotten to tangle with (between all seven movies) the Joker (three times), the Penguin (twice), Catwoman (twice), the Riddler (twice), Two-Face (twice), Mr. Freeze, Poison Ivy, Bane, the Scarecrow, Zsasz, Ra’s Ah Ghul, various familiar mobsters, and more. Granted, some of those versions sucked, but Batman’s variety was on display. Granted again, “Smallville” has beat the movies to the punch a few times, but what about Brainiac (with skull ship)? What about Bizarro? What about Bob? (sorry, got carried away).
At the very least, please replace the semi-obligatory montage of Superman stopping robbers and rescuing kittens with a montage that shows him taking on a couple of actual villains. You don’t need to deal with them past the montage; just give Superman some scope. Barring that, at least show him stopping a flood or catch a falling satellite rather than grabbing a cat burglar this time. He’s SUPERMAN for God’s sake.
4) Let Lois Know: Don’t be coy. Don’t be ambiguous. Let Lois know, and let us know she knows. Lois should be smart, even cunning. She should be a challenge to Clark/Kal both mentally and morally. What do I mean by morally? Lois as a crusading reporter should be a personality that pushes Superman to make real change in the world. Their conflicts could stem from her thinking that Superman isn’t actually doing enough in the face of the problems of the planet. That would be a different tack, and it could energize that relationship.
5) Appropriate Color: The “Returns” costume was too muted and Snyder’s previous films have occasionally been murky. Mr. Snyder: pump up the volume on the color. You have SUPERMAN. You have the weight of great production people behind you. Make this thing pop and sing. It doesn’t have to be “Speed Racer”, but it should be vibrant and alive. It’s SUPERMAN. He’s not Batman, and he’s damn sure not “Flash meets Silence of the Lambs” (really, who thought of that pitch, how bad was their childhood, and what drugs were they subsequently put on to make them suggest that?). Brighten it up. It won’t hurt anyone.
There’s my thoughts. What say you, readers?







