Blogs:

Newsarama Blogs Home > Article: UNCLE SCROOGE Comic Similar to INCEPTION, Confuses Bloggers

UNCLE SCROOGE Comic Similar to INCEPTION, Confuses Bloggers

August 3rd, 2010
Author Albert Ching

The mystery of Inception continues to deepen beyond even the reels of the film — just yesterday, we heard that Matthew Vaughn scrapped 12 pages of the X-Men: First Class script after seeing the movie, and today the blogosphere is absolutely consumed with the fact that the plot of Christopher Nolan’s latest hit is oddly similar to an Uncle Scrooge comic book, in which the dastardly Beagle Boys invade Uncle Scrooge’s dream, leaving Donald to have to go in and save the day.

Though that is certainly interesting — read more about it here — it’s also an intriguing study on the spread of information in the modern age. Or misinformation.

Few sources mention the specific comic that the story — by legendary Duck writer and illustrator Don Rosa — appeared in, Uncle Scrooge #329. I Watch Stuff, patient zero for much of these blog posts, said the comic came out in 2002, when it appears based on ComicVine and other sources to have been published in 2004. But both ComicVine and The Wrap say that it was published that year by BOOM! Studios, when that company didn’t exist until 2005 and didn’t start putting out Disney comics until 2008 — the comic was actually published by Diamond sister company Gemstone, who had the Disney license back then.

Then there’s Cinema Blend, where writer Josh Tyler says, “Oddly enough, I actually remember this comic. I used to read Uncle Scrooge as a kid, waiting in the corner of our local laundromat for my mom to finish folding clothes and these few panels bring back a lot of Zippy Mart memories.” Given that the Facebook link on Tyler’s Cinema Blend profile says he graduated high school in 1995, it seems, at the very least, highly unlikely that he was reading this particular comic in one of those instances. (Though a lot of Disney comics were published internationally before they were released in North America, so file it under “vaguely possible.”)

This post is getting as complex as Inception itself, but the important thing is this: it’s pretty awesome and more than a little surprising that a years-old Uncle Scrooge comic is so similar to a 2010 big-budget sci-fi blockbuster. A-woo-oo.

EDIT: Looks like the comic indeed came out in Europe in 2002, so props to I Watch Stuff for getting that right. Thanks to the commenters!

12 Responses to “UNCLE SCROOGE Comic Similar to INCEPTION, Confuses Bloggers”
  1. Sam Says:

    This should help:
    http://coa.inducks.org/story.php?c=D+2002-033

    Created in early 2002, published in various countries as early as late 2002, published in the US in 2004, again in 2006.

    Just to add to the conspiracy, Don Rosa (and you should mention somewhere that it’s a Don Rosa story, don’t you think?) says in his notes for the story that he got the basic idea for the story from an idea that a fan from France sent him.

  2. Gianfranco Goria - afnews.info Says:

    The firts time the story was published in Europe in 2002: http://coa.inducks.org/story.php?c=D+2002-033

  3. Albert Ching Says:

    Thanks guys!!

    Sam — definitely right about Rosa, I intended to include him all along, but somehow forget when getting hung up on when exactly the comic came out.

  4. Bob Cobb Says:

    > Don Rosa (and you should mention somewhere that it’s a Don Rosa story, don’t you think?) says in his notes for the story that he got the basic idea for the story from an idea that a fan from France sent him.

    And that story idea apparently came from a movie called The Cell. See http://dcf.outducks.org/viewtopic.php?pid=8492#p8492 .

  5. justsaying Says:

    What is the story that the hallway scene was lifted from the Gummi Bears Christmas Special? Heard that report but haven’t seen that cartoon.

  6. Chris Wenzel Says:

    ok, no i am hungry for gummi bears! thanks for that.

  7. research guy Says:

    One problem with all this. Nolen pitched this idea to the studio in 2000-2001. http://screencrave.com/2010-07-15/interview-christopher-nolan-for-inception/

  8. Spikey Says:

    And about thirty comic plots from the 80′s, a too many short stories to mention and a few low budget films as well.

  9. Albert Ching Says:

    research guy — no one seriously thinks that Christopher Nolan ripped off this comic. It’s just an amusing coincidence.

  10. Chi Straightening Irons Says:

    Advantageously, the post is actually the greatest topic on curing acne naturally. I concur with your conclusions and will eagerly look forward to your coming updates. Saying thanks will not just be enough, for the phenomenal lucidity in your writing. I will immediately grab your rss feed to stay informed of any updates.

  11. Clemente Gehrmann Says:

    Thanks for the imformative info.Very nice blog layout. Easy on the eyes. Thanks and happy holidays.

  12. Olga Tronaas Says:

    He is lifeless that is faultless. – English Proverb

Leave a Reply »