The Bronx Kill
Written by Peter Milligan
Illustrated by James Romberger
Lettered by Clem Robins
Published by DC/Vertigo
I love a good crime drama. Of course, I’m somewhat picky and I expect more from the genre than most of the pseudo-noir out there. Lesser writers resort to shallow posturing, tough guy clichés, and scantily dressed ingénues, slotted predictably into a plug-n-play.
Peter Milligan is not a lesser writer. The Bronx Kill is a potboiler in the best sense of the word. You’re reading the book, staring at it, waiting for events to occur, but Milligan’s just starting to simmer, building heat, creating tension, so that when it’s ready to pop, everything boils over in an instant.
Spending the first third of the book establishing his cast and their relationships, Milligan introduces us to his protagonist, Martin Keane, a writer caught in the orbit of his family’s history as police officers. His wife Erin copes with her own demons, but Milligan allows their dramas to unveil themselves slowly, mixing in plus characterization, terse family connections and scenes of quiet pleasantry to round out each cast member, and to ensure that the audience is able to connect with them.
When Erin goes missing, Martin’s life is thrown into tumult, and the time Milligan’s devoted to his ambitions, fears, loves and familial tensions – in addition to the careful character work given to Erin – pays off in spades.
Mixing pages of solid prose into the graphic narrative, Milligan takes readers inside the writing and imagination of Martin, exploring how life reflects fiction, and fiction life. The prose sections also show another side of Milligan’s talent, not only his ability to write prose well, but his ability to write mediocre prose and play with the form, adding hand-written “edits” and “author’s notes” in the margins as Martin writes and self-edits his newest novel.
James Romberger, a New Yorker, nails the atmosphere of Gotham. Working in pencil, Romberger’s illustrations are scratchy and nuanced, full of subtle shading and gradient lines. Atmospheric, cluttered, and full of characters suffused with confusion, loss and anger, each page reflects the emotional core of Milligan’s script and the physical truth of the city in which it occurs.
The Bronx Kill stands out from Vertigo’s crime fiction line of graphic novels, a gripping and emotional journey, beautifully illustrated, packed with a family’s ties, losses and betrayals. Readers looking for a thrilling mystery, supported by strong characters, that builds to a roiling boil would do well to check it out.








