Yesterday DC’s Source blog had a post entitled “Paul Cornell Steps in as New Action Comics Writer.” That was pretty surprising, given that Marc Guggenheim was just announced as stepping in as the new Action Comics writer, with June’s Action Comics #890 being solicited less than a month ago as the debut of “dynamic new creative team of Marc Guggenheim (Amazing Spider-Man) and Pete Woods.”
I’ve really enjoyed all of Cornell’s comics-writing work that I’ve read so far, particularly his unfortunately short-lived Captain Britain & MI13, which featured a terrific balance of character drama, humor, superhero action and zaniness…pretty much the exact formula of content I’d like to see in my Superman comics. So Cornell coming on to Action sure sounded like good news to me.
The exact wording of the announcement does give me a bit of pause though. From The Source post:
“I’m very bummed to be missing out on this chance to work with Marc who I think would have kicked some serious butt on ACTION. The story he pitched began to evolve into something quite different, something Marc knew would be great, but he had concerns about whether he was the man to write this tale. Rather than do a disservice to the book, the readers and himself, Marc decided to step away from ACTION, and we both know that sometime in the future, we’ll be collaborating on Superman for sure.
“With Guggs out of the picture, there was only one person to turn to, one writer who could bring this book to those Guggian heights while still making it his own—Paul Cornell. Shockingly, he accepted the challenge. In the short time we’ve been working together, his enthusiasm has blown me away!
Happily, no sooner had Marc stepped off than another editor swooped in to work with Marc on a project that will be announced in the near future.”
Does that sound like the story Guggenheim was intending to tell on Action Comics didn’t quite fit in a serial, 22-pages-a-month, should-sync-up-at-least-loosely-with-the-other-Superman-books book? Or that Guggenheim’s story didn’t fit with the Superman story that the editors and/or other writers wanted to tell in Action, and rather than force him to do it against his will they hired someone else?








