Blogs:

Newsarama Blogs Home > Article: Who will wield the (live action) shield?

Who will wield the (live action) shield?

February 24th, 2010
Author Lan Pitts

[Source: Heat Vision and pretty much the entire internet]

Reports are coming in about the possible contenders for the role of Captain American in Marvel Studios’ The First Avenger: Captain America. Apparently screen tests took place this past weekend and some interesting names came up. Of course Joe Johnson has said he had wanted to work with a relative unknown since the beginning.

Check these names out: John Krasinski, Michael Cassidy, Patrick Flueger, Scott Porter, Mike Vogel and Chace Crawford. Sure, you might know John Krasinski as Jim from NBC’s The Office, and perhaps Mike Vogel, who was in Cloverfield.

Now there is no guarantee that any of these guys will strap up Cap’s boots (and it’s weird to think most of them are my age), but I’m sure with Marvel holding the reins, they are sure to pick a winner and someone who will carry the character well.

So, Rama readers, of the suspects, who do you think (if any) will be the one to carry the shield?

11 Responses to “Who will wield the (live action) shield?”
  1. Wesley Smith Says:

    Ryan McPartlin, who plays Devon ‘Captain Awesome’ Woodcomb from “Chuck.” Although Awesome may be a little to close to what a parody of Captain America might be like.

  2. Ed Says:

    I can see someone like Krasinski as a pre-serum Steve, and then have a different actor as the post-serum Steve. But I’d sure they’ll probably do some cgi and use the same actor for both parts.

  3. Monetta Says:

    Jim from the Office? Really? Funny guy, but he looks like a cartoon character.

    Speaking of “Jim”, by the looks of some of these actors, they’ll need to hit a gym if they are going to play Cap.

  4. Shaun Says:

    Still disappointed that Aaron Eckhart and Mark Valley apparently aren’t being considered. I think both of those guys were practically born to play the role, AND they would match up nicely in terms of age, presence and gravitas when matched up with Robert Downey when The Avengers happens.

    The only name in this new bunch that I know is Krasinski, thanks to (duh) The Office. I wouldn’t have pictured that, but that old time football movie he was in with George Clooney gives me the idea that he’s probably got that build for it, or least would with some additional work. It’s an offbeat choice, to say the least, but it’s interesting.

    No opinions on the others, since I don’t know anything about them. I’m just glad to see Chris Pine NOT being mentioned. I don’t understand his appeal or why his name suddenly crops up with EVERY geek film being proposed now.

  5. Shaun Says:

    “I can see someone like Krasinski as a pre-serum Steve, and then have a different actor as the post-serum Steve. But I’d sure they’ll probably do some cgi and use the same actor for both parts.”

    Why couldn’t he just work out hard, ala Christian Bale did for the Batman movies? He’s actually a fairly big guy, not Steve Rogers-like, no, but it’s not out of the realm of possibility either.

  6. Ravager Says:

    jim from the office as captain america
    now thats interesting

  7. Rev. O.J. Flow Says:

    Of that list, I would take Krasinski (seeing him in LEATHERHEADS has actually sold me), Cassidy, maybe Porter, and Hedlund.

    Interesting wish list.

  8. Shaun Says:

    LEATHERHEADS… That was the name of the movie! Thank you, Rev.

    Yeah, I think Krasinski is an odd choice, but not a wholly terrible one.

  9. Cole Moore Odell Says:

    I think Krasinski could be inspired casting–his performance in Leatherheads opposite Clooney tells me he’d certainly hold his own alongside Downey in an Avengers picture; and he’s a big buy with a charismatic, likable presence, which a movie Captain America needs more than a chiseled face or washboard abs. Krasiniski makes Jim Halpert easy to root for on The Office, and I imagine that quality would serve him very well in this picture. There’s a lot more to casting these things than picking the guy who looks the most like he stepped out of the comic book.

  10. Daryll B Says:

    Wesley, I agree with you, Cap. Awesome from Chuck would make a great Captain America….

  11. Darrell Anton Says:

    That is some motivational material. Hardly ever believed that beliefs could possibly be this different. Cheers for all the commitment to deliver such helpful facts here.

Leave a Reply »