So I’m a little slow on the draw for this particular post — I’ve been meaning to write something about it, and other news got in the way — but I was interested to see Tom Brevoort talk about something that’s been on the minds of a lot of Avengers fans: will the classic lineup return?

We’ll use any and all of the classic Avengers characters as the situation demands it, of course, but those folks who are hoping for a full-blown reversal of the last ten years and a complete return to the Avengers of a decade ago are sadly in for a disappointment. And the reason for this should be obvious: in the last decade, AVENGERS has become the leading franchise in comics, and that’s in large part due to the alterations we made in the basic formula. I love the classic Avengers as much as the next person-and I edited them for a good, long time-but there are clearly so many more readers who are interested in the team and the book since we turned over the apple cart that there really isn’t any good reason to go back, other than nostalgia.
I’ll be honest, I was really sad to read this — even though I completely understand his point. It took me awhile to figure it out, but once I did, it was crystal clear: as someone who has been reading comics for the past decade and a half, I’ve always liked the Avengers more as an idea than in execution. (The one time that hasn’t been the case was the brief Geoff Johns run on the book — and even then, I didn’t really dig the book until he teamed up with Oliver Coipel for the Red Zone arc.) Because despite the archetypes being used in this book — which really do rival the Big Seven JLA in a lot of ways — a lot of times the book felt jumbled. Cramped. Suffocated by continuity and story arcs that just felt inconsequential.
In response to that, Marvel decided to do their own take on the Justice League model — ie, assemble their most popular characters for a team. Now, as someone who has been reading the current Avengers books, they aren’t series that leap off the shelves and mug me for my hard-earned dollars — for me, the tone doesn’t quite float my boat, even despite Brian Michael Bendis’ talents with Luke Cage and Ultimate Comics Spider-Man. (Which I adore.) But for a lot of people, it makes sense — it’s Captain America, Iron Man, Spider-Man, and Wolverine teaming up, it sets the tone for crossovers for the rest of the Marvel Universe, and they dig Brian Michael Bendis’ dialogue, and that’s enough for them. It’s SOMETHING in the Avengers’ favor, when for so long it was hampered by continuity and Z-list characters. (Gilgamesh, I’m looking at you!)
But the question I have it this: when Hollywood — and thus, the general non-comics-reading public — see the Avengers, they will see something closer to the classic mold, with Cap, Iron Man, Thor, The Black Widow, The Hulk, and maybe Hawkeye or Ant-Man or the Wasp in the mix as well. Will Marvel rework the Avengers to fit that mold, as they gave Spidey his black costume back when Spider-Man 3 hit theatres? Or is the classic lineup now more Mark Millar’s domain, with the Ultimate Avengers? In Marvel’s defense, one could easily say that if you want your classic Avengers, look no further than that.
I don’t know for certain. I know that Brian Michael Bendis has done a lot to bring in the bajillion new readers to the Avengers books, which puts them higher up on the Top 300 comics lists month after month than they probably ever were. But, to play Devil’s Advocate, I also feel like comics writing has really ramped up its standards of quality in the past 10 years — taking more of a page from blockbuster cinema as opposed to soap opera — and I wonder if a classic Avengers lineup written under those conditions, with an Ed Brubaker or Matt Fraction playing up the archetypes’ potential, wouldn’t do well enough to make it worth Marvel’s while. What do you think? Are the New Avengers more archetypal than the Avengers Classic? If you wanted a return to the classic line, who do you think would be able to pull it off? Sound off!