I don’t envy Dwayne McDuffie.
A long-time comics writer and a fairly successful presence in the animation world, he seemed to hit the jackpot with his latest assignment for DC Comics: Writing Justice League of America, which, at the time he took over in late 2007, was the company’s biggest hit, thanks in large part to the previous writer Brad Meltzer’s short run.
So not only was McDuffie getting the opportunity to write DC’s number one team made up of some of the biggest and most popular superheroes in the world, it was already a massive hit. It sure seems like it would have been a dream job, at least from where I sit.
Well, as it turns out, it looks like it may have been one of those blessing-is-actually-a-curse, your-son-comes-home-from-war-but-is-a-zombie, monkey’s paw type situations. The book seems to have come with a lot of strings attached.
During the twenty issues and one special that constituted McDuffie’s run, it has been used to launch, set-up or tie-in to miniseries Tangent: Superman’s Reign, Salvation Run (itself a Countdown tie-in), Final Crisis and Justice League: A Cry For Justice, as well as introducing the Milestone characters into the DCU and, in the latest few issues, reflecting the changes in various other books (Wonder Woman, the Superman and Batman books, etc). That’s a lot of writing about what other people are writing about to cram into 22 pages a month, while still maybe trying to tell your own story around the edges (made more difficult by how much the previous writer left unresolved, for whoever followed him to either completely ignore or clean up for him).
By Chris Eckert’s count, there have been sixteen pencillers and twenty-three inkers so far, leaving McDuffie without a real partner to help establish a look, feel or tone for the book (as well as furthering the image of a book lurching in a different direction month after month).
Back in February, a commenter on McDuffie’s message board asked him if he even enjoyed writing JLoA since “it just seems to be constant editorial rewrites and bad art,” and McDuffie responded rather simply, “No, I don’t.”
On Monday, gossip columnist Rich Johnston trawled a long thread on the DC message board for juicy quotes from McDuffie about his work on the title, and the results were revealing.
McDuffie speaks plainly (and, it should be pointed out, quite politely) about some of the difficulties of writing DC’s flagship title, since most of the cast is on loan from other writers and editorial offices (That is, if the Batman creators are killing of Bruce Wayne for a year and putting someone else in the cape and cowl, obviously Bruce Wayne will be missing some Justice League meetings).
While he doesn’t say so, I imagine this is all the harder given DC’s current publishing strategy of doing big, DCU-shaking events like Final Crisis and Blackest Night, with smaller, character-specific events like “Battle For the Cowl,” and “World Without Superman” and so on occurring in between.
So not only were his long-term plans constantly being changed to reflect the rest of the DC line’s stories, he increasingly found it hard just to fill the chairs around the meeting table:
Beyond that, The Hawks, Green Arrow, both Atoms, Captain Marvel and almost everyone I think of as either a big gun, or a traditional JLA favorite are likewise not available. So as we wait for things to settle down in the other titles, I’m doing “Cap’s Kooky Quartet.” Of course, in this case Captain America isn’t available, either.
I gave that some thought for much of the week, as Justice League line-ups have been on my mind a lot lately, ever since Dan DiDio asked Newsarama readers, “What would you consider the perfect team for the Justice League of America, and why?”* (Although, honestly, I spend a lot of time thinking about the Justice League anyway).
And you know, as big as the DC Universe is, so much of it does seem off-limits to League membership at the moment. Of the original seven, Batman, Aquaman and Martian Manhunter are all (temporarily) dead, Superman’s on vacation and Wonder Woman’s…busy, I think she said.
So this is the current League line-up, according to the roll call in the last issue of the title:
Green Lantern John Stewart
Dr. Light II
Firestorm II
Vixen
Zatanna
and mmmayybe Black Canary.
DC has so many team titles at the moment—Titans, Teen Titans, JSoA, Outsiders—that just about every hero primarily associated with another franchise is already starring in another team book, making promoting most of them to the JLA difficult. In fact, these books have even re-absorbed recent League members (Flash and Red Arrow are in Titans, Black Lightning and Geo-Force are in Outsiders). Even the DC teams that don’t actually have ongoing books or miniseries at the moment seem to still be extant off-panel, with The Freedom Fighters, Doom Patrol, Metal Men and Shadow Pact eating up even more of the DC’s superheroes with League potential. Oh, and the New Gods are all out too, pending the end of their post-Final Crisis fallow period.
If McDuffie wanted to use former Leaguers, and pick ones that aren’t currently on a superhero team or involved in a status quo that would prevent them from joining (like Booster Gold or Fire, for example), well, he’s limited the likes of Huntress, Steel, Plastic Man, um, Blue Jay…Maya…Faith, and, um…is Green Arrow II still alive? How about Tasmanian Devil?
So yeah, despite the thousands of characters, many of them with unrealized potential, McDuffie doesn’t seem to have a lot to choose from at the moment, certainly not any that will make his current kooky quintet seem any less kooky.
He could always create new characters, of course, as he does have a pretty rare opportunity to inject some original creations into the fabric of the DCU, but it’s quite understandable why any writer might be reluctant to do so, given the current realities of the comics industry. (If McDuffie has a great idea for the next Superman, or even the next Booster Gold, why sign it over to DC when he could benefit more from a creator-owned endeavor with the character?)
So what’s left?
Well, McDuffie could just go ahead and do something super-crazy. It’s clear the Justice League book is in something of a temporary holding pattern, waiting for current and near-future storylines to end before moving forward, giving the writer the opportunity to try something really, really unexpected.
Here are some probably extremely unrealistic suggestions:
(more…)