(Spoiler after the jump, so don’t click if you haven’t read the issue yet!)
…the person who just stuck a very sharp chunk of metal a few inches into the torso of current Robin Tim Drake (dressed as Batman above, bleeding profusely) wasn’t former Robin Jason Todd (also dressed like Batman, walking away saying, “Just one more to go”), who was resurrected via dubious agency after having been dead himself for 16 years real time.
That’s the problem with these sorts of resurrections. A problem which is perhaps much worse when the characters aren’t super-people and the books the resurrections occur in are more realistic, street-level ones like those of Batman franchise than, say, The Flash or Superman, where the god-like super-being protagonists exist in a milieu full of constant comic book science, time travel and magic.
Certainly every reader knows that if a massively unpopular character who suffered an equivocal here’s-the-body, there’s-the-funeral death like Jason Todd can be brought back to life, there’s no reason to worry about the fate of his more popular successor. Even if you were worried Tim Drake was going to die due to the grievous, mortal wound he receives at the end of this issue, you would be comforted by the knowledge that someone will be bringing him back to life eventually, be it next fall or in 16 years or in 23 years.
Not that DC really wants you to think that they were really going to ahead and kill of Tim Drake in this series. I mean, this week’s DC Nation column ran a cover for a book called Red Robin featuring two people dressed in Robin costumes, and we know there’s a third Robin showing up in the upcoming Grant Morrison-written Batman and Robin title. Surely one of them has gotta be Tim Drake. Still, it would be kind of nice if they at least pretended things like this were meant to be suspenseful, wouldn’t it?
By the way, what’s up with Tim’s physique in that picture above? For a sixteen-year-old kid, he’s one massive dude. He’s going to look like the Incredible Hulk if he hits another growth spurt before graduation.
April 10th, 2009 at 10:25 am
i enjoyed issue 1, but issue 2 was horrible, lets just get past this and get on to batman and robin in june by morrison, i am still debating whether to get batman by winnick when his run starts
April 10th, 2009 at 11:48 am
I think Tim is 18 atleast now. They had that whole “One Year Later” thing a couple years ago. Unless that’s all been wiped out.
April 10th, 2009 at 2:30 pm
y’know we even though Tim and Dick, have called this guy Jason, he hasn’t really said “Ah ha you’ve got me I’m Jason Todd!” yet.
So while I agree Tim Drake isn’t dead, I still don’t know who this mystery Bat-guy is yet.
I mean, we still don’t know what Bruce said to Jason in that chamber thingie. But really would Bruce give this little nutcase the means and blessing to run around as Bat-Psycho? Well, I hope not.
April 10th, 2009 at 3:49 pm
It works. I don’t think it’s supposed to be a cliffhanger. I think of it more as building up Jason Todd as a heel. That’s what this whole issue was. Making him a credible threat for Dick in the third issue. We’re not supposed to think Tim is dying/dead, just that he’s defeated and out of the running. Next month: the main event.
April 10th, 2009 at 5:07 pm
fernald:
“But really would Bruce give this little nutcase the means and blessing to run around as Bat-Psycho? Well, I hope not.”
One sentence for you:
Jean-Paul Valley.
April 10th, 2009 at 5:29 pm
what?!
you seriusly believe that is Jason?
honestly i dont think the botc have been that good so far
the horrible characterization of Damien plus other covenient factors like the recent and without explanation return of blackmask, the destruction of arkham and now the police HQ,
the death of gotham DA was really obvius since kate spencer was gonna be the new one but he still got 2-3 pages of unnnecesary talking with gordon and the fact that tim manage to locate evil batman`s batcave in like 15 mins -__-
its obvius who is gun-batman
his name is Jean Paul Valley, Azrael
April 10th, 2009 at 7:24 pm
I don’t care who it is… I just hope that when it’s all said and done Jason is killed off, forever preferably, and I can come back to Batman comics and pretend he was never revived in the first place. Then again, I’ll be waiting for Bruce’s return before I pick up another Bat-book anyhow.
As much as I dislike DC’s direction in general, and the Bat-books in particular, under Didio I thank him for saving me lots of cash.