In yesterday’s Journalista, Dirk Deppey offered a stinging critique of Lisa Fortuner’s recent column, as well as the recent campaign to get Stephanie Brown her own Batcave memorial:

Don’t believe the hype. If the Girl Wonder crowd were really concerned with making superhero comics safe for 13-year-old girls, they’d be arguing over far, far more than statues, Playboy, or Stephanie Brown. They’d be arguing that their favorite comics should again be written exclusively for children. They’d demand a return to (and stricter enforcement of) the Comics Code Authority, that a sharper line of demarcation be drawn between kiddie comics and those for the existing fanbase, and that virtually all of Marvel and DC’s main line of product be placed firmly on the children’s side of the line. They’d demand an end to decades of continuity, so as to allow new readers every opportunity to jump onboard. They’d demand more female comics creators and more women in management, and assurances that women have a voice on the board of directors for the CCA. In other words, if “think of the children” really were at the core of this argument, an authentic feminist agenda would be centered around actually thinking of the children, and not their own tastes and inclinations. What adherents of such an agenda wouldn’t waste their time over is anything involving statues, Playboy or Stephanie Brown. They’d have bigger fish to fry.

Heidi MacDonald offers a somewhat similar, though more polite, response:

Seems like a good first step to us, but don’t give up the fight just yet, ladies. We say don’t rest until you get a female superhero book that’s actually suitable for young women to read. Now that would be a real accomplishment.

This entry was posted on Tuesday, February 5th, 2008 at 7:49 am and is filed under DC Comics, Internet, News & Views. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.