Okay, one of the big topics this week seems to be “the Death of the New Gods”. Naturally, almost everyone seems to have something to say about it.
The Occasional Superheroine asserts that it’s hard to dislike the series:
Why? Because it’s Jim Starlin. DC really dodged the bullet on this whole miniseries by getting Starlin to write and draw it. Because it’s like if you put Marv Wolfman & George Perez on Countdown — yeah, it’s another editorially-mandated clusterf**k but how can you dislike it when you’ve got such legendary creators on it? It would be like hating Stan Lee. Which is like hating Comics. There’s some math in there.
If you’re familiar with Starlin’s work with characters like Captain Marvel or Warlock at all, you understand that this guy’s a master of the Cosmic Story — probably right behind Kirby in that regard. So if you get bogged down or confused by metaphysical/galactic sentences like:
“They’d actually taken the Source’s cryptic meanderings and sculpted them into the foundation of a ridiculous little religious fantasy,”
rest assured that it all has some higher spiritual purpose and that God will probably make an appearance in the third act, even if He is in the form of a section of drywall or a Nerf ball with Kirby crackle emanating from it.
Paul S., or Goggle_Kid, is annoyed by the execution:
That said I am supremely displeased with the death of Big Barda. I’m not against the concept of killing off Big Barda in a book titled “The Death of the New Gods,” but good lord could the execution have been any worse? This is quite possibly the least fitting most crap-tastic superhero death scene since poor Steph Brown’ General-hospital esc deathbed scene in Batman: War Games. I mean for god’s sake… she was shot in the chest while putting away groceries. That kind of death scene might have been fitting for a character like Linda Park West or Lana Lang, but Barda sure as hell deserved better than such a stereotypical Superhero wife/girlfriend death.
For starters killing off Barda this early in the game is a patently stupid move as well, Barda is the Jack Kirby Fourth World character for people who don’t care about Jack Kirby’s Fourth World. She is arguably the most popular forth world character, and the most recognizable to younger readers due to her appearances in Birds of Prey and Grant Morrison’s JLA run. People who don’t care the slightest about more obscure Fourth World characters like Mark Moonrider or Metron probably picked this up because they were expecting to see Barda go out in some big cosmic battle scene, not in something that plays like a deleted subplot from Identity Crisis.
Sleestak explains why he’s not upset:
Would I like Barda and pals to remain static and never change? Sure I would. I love them as they are. But even in the current creative climate of fast and loose continuity all characters must evolve or at least have the illusion of growth. There are some amazingly bad and goofy concepts in there and many characters, like Desaad, are criminally misused and weakly portrayed at best. A re-imagining is probably the best way to go about making the Fourth World characters a bit more interesting and contemporary.
So I figure that what is being torn out of the New Gods isn’t so much as their hearts, but the “God Essence” that makes them what they are. The body is merely a shell that is unimportant and can be left behind. Of course, knowing Starlin, the divine spark that is being forcibly recalled from the gods is probably being used as fuel for some ultimate weapon of destruction by a villain or anti-hero. In the end I suspect that all the captured souls will be reformed into an all new pantheon of Gods for DC to play with.
While our own Lisa Fortuner explains why probable impermanence isn’t a comfort:
Maybe its because I’ve seen enough cool female characters killed off then not resurrected as planned (Arisia) or resurrected only to have the death remain in continuity while the resurrection is forgotten (Katma Tui) already that this bugs me. That its a first-issue death that might be undone soon doesn’t really soften this blow.
So what do you think?