Blogs:

Newsarama Blogs Home > Article: The Fifth Color – Hulk Move On

The Fifth Color – Hulk Move On

February 28th, 2007
Author Carla Hoffman

the fifth color

Getting personal for a second, let me just say that I like the Hulk. A lot. But I hadn’t always; growing up, I saw some of the TV show and snored through it. I only bought one comic of the big green guy at my first comic shop tenure, and that was due to the subject matter (PAD did AIDS before Winick shed his Real World days!). I did what most people did: looked at the cover, saw a big monster throwing truck and based my opinion from that.

A friend of mine changed all of that. He’s the one who got me to actually open a book and look inside, something very integral to all Marvel characters. While someone can take a look at Superman or Batman and get their gist (Superman, dressed in red and blue, sailing through the sky, Batman, dark, normally hunched in shadows, lookin’ mean), you really have to find out about guys like Spider-Man to learn about Great Power and Responsibility and the real heart of their stories. Thus it was with the Hulk; one of the first things I read was Incredible Hulk: Beauty and the Behemoth (from the House of Ideas!) with Peter David’s forward and afterward, and I found a remarkable romance within the character and got that all important connection that grabs most readers from the House that Stan Built: character identification.

Back issue after back issue was added to my collection as a love of Peter David (from his Star Trek novels) and an understanding of Bruce Banner hooked me line and sinker. I’m a 98-lb. weakling, folks. I got pushed around in school as a kid. I came from a really loud family and I’m a huge bookworm. The Hulk was made for me with all the daydreams of just freaking out and going postal on those things we’re all powerless against: idiots, adveristy and ourselves. I mean, it’s not hard to see that Banner’s worst enemy is himself, there’s no stretched metaphors here. Guy gets angry, turns into a monster and smashes, reverting back as he calms down to deal with what’s left behind. Who hasn’t done something in the heat of anger than they have honestly regretted? Now, take that and tack on throwing a tank. It’s fantastic, but human at the same time.

I love Bruce Banner. I think he’s a fantastic character with the burden he carries. It’s why I tune in to see what he’s up to, looking in on that part of ourselves that can totally screw up and yet redeem themselves time and again. I caught an old episode of the TV series (the one that used to put me to sleep as a kid) and now watching it with the background I have, I have no idea why this couldn’t be translated into a comic series.

Guy wanted for crimes he didn’t commit? Traveling from town to town while eluding those who would hunt him down? Running into people who need help that he has decide on how he could possibly aid them without royally screwing it all up? Then walking away when it’s all done, moving on to the next town… It’s very western in a way, could go episodic if there’s not a unifying plot to thread through, could handle writing changes and different artists when things get sticky release-date-wise. But at heart, it’s a good premise. Not only do you get versatility with your smashing and awesome Hulk-itude, but you have multitude of ways to get across the heart of the man behind the monster. Someone who may be puny, but is stronger than you or I could ever be.

And I will never get this story. The Marvel Universe has changed so drastically, ideas I wanted to see explored back in the day have had the book closed on them. There’s a superhero team in every state, the wandering hero has no place. Hulk has been charged, tried and found guilty of being a danger to himself and others and was sent into space, punishment found fitting and hands wiped clean. Sure, World War Hulk is on the horizon, but it’s not like the Hulk is going to start a war and then get back to the old status quo. Bruce Banner himself is no longer a character, just a shadow of the Hulk, recently seen only when he feels weakness. It’s been nearly a year and only in the last issue (#103 for those of your counting at home) has Bruce Banner shown up to say a few words on the Hulk’s behalf. And with SHIELD in charge and all heroes unified towards a common goal, there is no running from the law.

While exciting, Marvel’s brave new world closed the doors on a lot of previous standards and plotlines for characters. I mean, just look at Robbie Baldwin. But with great power comes great responsiblity and as powerful a storyarc as Civil War was (like it or hate it, we all had an opinion on it so it’s justifiably powerful here), there should still be a responsibility to the characters put through all this change. They still need to be the same heroes and villains that we connected with in the first place, no matter how wild and wacky things get around them. So, while I may never get my hitchhiking man-cum-monster, traveling from town to town solving mysteries and smashing bad guys, that doesn’t mean that the Hulk I connected with in my awkward youth won’t still be in the books. The surroundings can change but the character at heart, that honest truth that connects us to these heroes (or villains), should always remain the same.

4 Responses to “The Fifth Color – Hulk Move On”
  1. kidvictory Says:

    I agree about the possibilities the tv series theme with the comic conventions could provide.

    It could turn back to that one day, but for now we’re getting something totally different – which is a welcomed breath of fresh air. For too long the Hulk has had false starts or not the focus he deserves. Hopefully WWH will quench our green thrist.

    And when the dust settles, who knows where Bruce will be . . . maybe hitching a ride to another town . . . where there’s always a superhero group watching . . .

    Imagine a Marvel Hero police state and a wandering Bruce Banner?

    Hmmmmmm

  2. pulse768 Says:

    I can hear the lonesome piano music now…

  3. Joel Kelly Says:

    I hate to say it, but for the first time in my life, I am regularly reading and loving the Hulk, and I cringe every time the idea of Bruce Banner coming back comes up. I too am the classic 98-pound weakling, bookworm, etc. I like the Hulk because he is my opposite; if I want to know about Bruce B. I can look in the mirror – I want to see the angry, misunderstood giant who is the strongest one there is. He is the interesting character – Frankenstein as nuclear-age threat.

  4. The Mutt Says:

    In addition to losing the David Banner Walking Away Music, we’ve also lost any reasonable chance for a Lone Hero against Impossible Odds story or a Street Level Crime Fighter over-matched against a World-Destroying Menace story. Help is always a phone call away. Wasn’t the whole point of House of M to reduce the surplus superpowered population? Now we’ve got capes around every corner again, and new ones being made every day. I didn’t recognize half of the characters in the background action of Civil War as it is.

Leave a Reply »