I think Kelly’s been doing a decent enough job writing a good supporting cast(if not Supergirl herself), that I can’t really support a campaign to bump him off the title. He’s doing a much better job than Loeb did at least.

Now, one that’d put Sean on Green Arrow(being the single DC title most needing a change) is another story.

What does that do to Supergirl and the LSH then?

I think that Waid’s been doing a wonderful job writing a much sweeter, more innocent Kara there.

Can the market really handle three Supergirl titles, even if they had fairly different audiences??

And for what it’s worth, my piece of the Supergirl pie is the 80 issue series by PAD, which is one of the most heartfelt, thought-provoking, spiritual and fun superhero titles I’ve ever read. But I’m not getting that piece back.

If this means that Supergirl could leave Legion so the title becomes good again i encourage it, it really is a shame how bad that comic has gotten

I think Kelly is making the book work despite a bumpy transition from Loeb and the intervening Crisis nonsense. Has anyone thought that McKeever might be tired of writing romance comics and wants to do something else? His recent interview hints that he wants to do other kinds of things.
Plus, Supergirl so far is not the kind of character that would fit well into a Spidey F*KS MJ style book. She’s much more of a kickass chik as presented so far.

I want McKeever to get the higher profile projects he deserves and for Supergirl to keep going as is. I also don’t see how readers can call for even more Supergirl books since the two existing titles featuring her are not exactly lighting up the sales charts. Still both are much better than Flash or Wonder Woman.

Del Gorky — Since when would Supergirl be a romance book? I figured he would be good because he could write for young girls, not because of romance. Typically, a book for young girls has a prominent female character.

A Supergirl book wouldn’t need romance to make a female character important, since the female character is already the star.

Ditto what Lisa said…When I’m thinking a Spider-Man Loves Mary Jane kind of book, I’m talking about outreach potential and not necessarily as a romance book. I think there’s plenty of kick-ass potential in such a book reaching out to girls.

um, i love reading supergirl because unlike her cousin she is a toublemaker, she isn’t a girl scout, nor is she a goodie, goodie like Superman. Kara is always causeing or getting to trouble. it causes probables for every one else. if they make her less dark, and not so much of a badass girl, that i would think would kill the series. I personally like the spoiled rotten brat supergirl she is much better the any of the supergirls before. they were all terriable and basically just a girl version of superman while this supergirl is totally different in that she is his complete oppiste. this is why i like supergirl but hate superman. for me has long has she stays badass and a brat i dont care who is wrighting it. thats the ways she is on tv too, shows like superman tas, Justice league unlimied and smallville. a change like that could hurt her popularity.