The Bendis Board asks: What comic was the biggest disappointment of 2006?:
“for me, gotta say infinite crisis. i bought in, y’know. i truly bought in and i felt let down in almost every way. deaths that weren’t deaths(nightwing), incomplete and rushed art, story edits and fixes in a hardback money grab, the culmination and resolution of major plot points (the minis) in books (the mini specials) other than the one book (ic) we were promised they would culminate and resolve in, a battle of metropolis with every major super goodie and baddie involved over in less than half an issue, 12 issues of sprawling story crammed into 7 and pouring out the overstuffed sides… it was a fine read. entertaining enough, i guess. but i bought in. thought it was going to be epic. all the build-up, the minis, prelude, geoff johns! i believed, and in the end, it just didn’t work for me.”
“The first four issues of Civil War… Clor. That says enough by itself on that issue. Iron Man finally offers Cap a chance to talk things out, explain some of his ideas, you know, just be rational adults instead of destroying NYC every time some of them go outside, and when he offers a friendly handshake? Cap sucker punches him. Completely out of character.”
“Grant Morrison’s Batman. I was expecting so much, like Batman’s New X-Men. Plus, how can you go wrong with 50 ninja man-bats? Somehow he found a way. And I was so looking forward to it. I guess there is still the hope that it could get better… hey, it could… maybe.”
“I’m gonna say Black Panther. I love the character, but his book this year has been nothing but one big money-grubbing, publicity-grabbing event that was hastily executed without any thought on what it would do for the characters involved, other than their public profile. But I love the character, so I keep buying and I feel like a tool.”
“[Civil War] has had its delays, and ,for me at least, those delays are just now starting to piss me off. an event that was supposed to pop has instead been on a slow simmer for 4 months. but the story has stayed true throughout and looks to be something that may indeed actually reimagine the marvel universe, something that respects the past and looks to the future. i mean, there’s still a chance, a damn good chance having read lots of millar, that civil war’s payoff is gonna be as big as its promise.
and one thing we know for certain, marvel is going to be a different place post-cw, characters are going to be forever (5 years at least) changed.”
I love the “forever (5 years at least)” bit. But now it’s your turn, Newsablogreaders. What was your most disappointing book of the year?