The Bendis Board reacts to Joe Quesada’s comments about DC trying to Marvelize, from last Friday:
“I think Quesada can be a bit petty at times, but I’m not going to say he shouldn’t be sniping at the competition. If anything, I think DC needs to get nastier and stop thinking of themselves as ‘the old, respectable company’ that doesn’t sink to that level.”
“I dont care if he’s wrong or right, but that was well spoken and well articulated. He could have been an asshole about it and really put DC down hard. Was there any need for it, probably not, but for what it was it was well said.”
“Sometimes Joe Q does rattle the cage but it’s always been like this DC is good but… they never had a Stan Lee type figure who goes out there and talks to the fans. Joe Q has his own weekly interview with Newsarama the only close thing I’ve seen DC doing is 5.2 but thats in relation to 52 more then anything else [...] In this case it’s a well thought out view, to me DC heroes have been very distant and somewhat hard to relate to, and no amount of bumbling Clark Kent does will ever make me think otherwise.”
“Very classy indeed and hopefully dc can listen to joe so it can be a decent company again.”
“Not really, given how Marvel is a perfect comic book company and DC’s characters are so inherently weak for the purposes of storytelling that they will never produce stories as good as what Marvel has to offer. It’s science.”
“It’s useful to stick with a phrase like marvelize, because that could mean a number of intangibles regarding characterization, stories,art, hiring specific creators, etc . That’s 1969 talk, and frankly both watches what the other does and copies the other’s best ideas. (cough vertigo cough) [...] If anyone truly believes Marvel has been the only innovator in comics during the last 40 plus years, then you’re just sipping kool-ade brewed by the house of ideas.”
“I know the guy takes a lot of shit online, but it has to be said: he’s one of the most intelligent, well spoken men in the industry. No EIC can ever be perfect, but the man brings a fresh perspective to the company, and he’s really concerned about helping the industry, which, as someone that wants to work in the industry, I have the utmost respect for. I agree with him. I think DC needs to take a close look at some of their characters. I find DC’s crop of characters, for the most part, unrelatable. The last time I was really interested in any of them was during Morrison’s tenure on JLA. I loved the portrayal of Kyle Rayner, Wally West and Plastic Man. In fact, I kind of liked seeing how Kyle felt like these characters were too big to relate to.”
“No one’s saying DC wasn’t trying to copy Marvel in the beginning. They were new, fresh, and doing things very differently. Of course DC should try to copy a thing or two. But he acts as if DC’s still doing it. DC and Marvel have been on the same even writing keel since the 80’s. Neither side is doing anything different or grandiose than the other one. All the stories tend to be recycled through as many realistic filters as possible. The only real difference here is Marvel doesn’t have as many corporate people looking down wanting to make sure the characters will always be licensable the same way so they have more oppurtunity to rock the boat. DC usually does follow up when they can but in a different storytelling ability. But Joe always wants to act as if to say ‘Marvel always does things first.’ And its not true.”