…that, as amusing as Harlan Ellison’s lawsuit against Gary Groth, Kim Thompson and Fantagraphics may be, it’s not the only lawsuit that Mr. Ellison is currently engaged in, as Peter David has already pointed out:
Readers of Harlan Ellison’s webpage–and even some non-readers–are aware that Harlan is launching a legal action against Pocket Books over current and upcoming novels about Edith Keeler.
Quite a few folks have been asking me if this will have any impact on “Imzadi” which, as anyone who has read it knows, is basically an inversion of “City” and features the Guardian of Forever. Although I already suspected the answer, I called Harlan and he personally assured me that “Imzadi” will not be a part of the litigation, for two reasons: First, he’d never cause a close friend that kind of grief, and second, way back in the day when I first came up with the plot, I called him and asked permission. He gave me the okay, I wrote the book, and dedicated it to him.
Now, back to internet reaction to the Ellison/Fantagraphics case. The Engine takes it all in its stride, for the most part. Warren Ellis:
A lot of it feels like it was put through Harlan’s typewriter.
Matt Fraction:
I’m more thrown by the revelation that gary and kim run fanta out of the home they both share, and that they once absconded with legal funds to take a secret tropical vacation together.
Jonathan Hickman, of Image’s The Nightly News:
Easily the best thing I’ve read this week. That man certainly knows when he has an audience.
Meanwhile, reaction on The Comics Journal site is one of stunned bemusement:
If Harlan wrote the complaint himself, it’s the best writing out of him I’ve seen for many a Barry Longyear. “…there was no reasoning with or apologizing to the temperamental Fleisher; he was determined to sue and in fact he did.” Elsewhere: “This is a grotesque and ludicrous fabrication, a florid lie.” Wow, that stuff just jumps off the page at you.
Alex Buchet is taking things slightly more seriously, however:
[I]f you are or were an employee of, or contractor to, or vendor to, or supplier of Fantagraphics or the Comics Journal:
Do not post to this thread.
Ellison and his legal mercenaries have reserved the right to amend his complaint to include anyone and his/her brother in his suit. (John Does 1 to 20.)
Take heed, John Linton R. and others, lest you be subpoenaed. Matt Silvie, restrain your tongue of acid silver. Tom Spurgeon, contact your lawyer NOW.
Needless to say, this is developing. Those with an interest in such things, the complaint is well worth a read, and deserving of the comments above.